Ursula had been making noises that she was interested in this “new email thing” and that it might be practical to be able to order groceries for home delivery. Given my addiction to electronics I needed little encouragement to hit the Apple store for laptop printer and router provision cable broadband and set up a home network for mom. What I should have recalled was (i) I have never been long on patience as a teacher or otherwise and (ii) the last piece of technology my mother had mastered was the IBM Selectric II typewriter. Never having made the transition to fax word processor or mobile phone let alone first generation PC my mother had missed successive waves of tech learning. We tend not to think about it much in large part because it has become second nature but manufacturers of everything from cars to microwave ovens expect that every half-literate adult can operate a touch screen choose options from a set of radial buttons scroll down a screen and manipulate a mouse. Not Grandma.
Thanks to the good nature of my wife and my occasional emergency intervention my mother has almost mastered the power button and has managed to send a couple of Gmails. There are of course some humorous misadventures and questions. I particularly appreciated Ursula’s query when she was having trouble sending an email to a relative in Israel with a “.il” rather than a “.com” address. In the age of the world wide web (ps. that’s a clue Mom) my mother asked whether perhaps the reason she was getting message failures was that we had not paid for “long distance” service.
Equally charming was the time Ursula failed to send us a welcome home message and her Mac said there was a problem with the “Airport.” I later assured her that we had breezed through customs at JFK but that her wireless Apple Airport was the culrprit. There was also the time I got nervous call from my mother worrying that she would be convicted of trademark infringement because I had set her password to include a very common proper name. I only wish that I had been so good a lawyer as to have worried about such an attenuated claim.
What my mother kept asking for was a set of written instructions which could demystify the computer for her or at least guide her down a narrow path to accomplish the handful of things she wanted to do. While I did hide icons to simplify her screen and set up programs to remember her user ID and password I could not give her a simple set of instructions to cover all issues that might appear or fail to appear on her screen. While she insisted that the kids and I must have learned how to use this “wretched machine” in school I came to realize that we had learned through simple trial and error. Unfortunately my advice that she should “hang loose stay agile and experiment” in the face of confusing warning messages did not have its intended pedagogic effect.
While my mother may not be thrilled that I am sharing her technology travails quite so publicly I think it is a good challenge. I will tell her there are some amusing stories about her on my blog and see if she can find her way here. If she does and then commits a very late term abortion of her only son as a result I know I will have succeeded in my mission.
I have wanted to similarly “tech-enable” my mother-in-law for many years but she too has little to no interest in computers. We did try to crack the wall this Christmas with a new Kindle. So far I have not had a tech support call yet so I am cautiously optimistic that the Christmas day instruction session was successful. Either that or the new Kindle may be gathering that first thin lay of dust somewhere on an out-of-the-way table top.
Great post Tom! It took me eight years to teach my mom e-mail (in year seven the occasional email still reached me all squeezed in the subject line) but once she had mastered that Skype only took one additional year. The problem for people who haven’t grown up with technology is like you describe they’d prefer step-by-step written instructions. Unfortunately the modern desktop metaphor is more obstacle than help to this process compared to the earlier interaction paradigm of command-line commands (MS-DOS UNIX Linux) because the verbal description has to presuppose familiarity with the metaphor (what’s a window? why would I want to move it around if I just want to print a document?). Graphical desktops can be in very different configurations so the same instructions may work one day but not another or on one machine but not the next. There’s still a case for keyboard commands (also for the expert/professional user).
I have been a passive reader of your blog for some time but couldn’t resist to comment on this. I must say that either a) your wife is a great teacher or b) your mother is a genius or c) both. I have been trying to teach my 54-year old mother for last 3 year. However I should mention that the last thing she mastered on was an old manual Remington type writer.
How about to buy an iPad? That may more easier for Grandma or little child to handle. My 3 years little girl love to use it very much.
Your post took me back to mid 1980s when computers were new to everyone. I remember hearing about some of the calls to Microsoft where they were famous for great customer service (and patience I might add). A woman had the technician on the phone for quite a while complaining that her printer would print every color except yellow. She didn’t tell the tech she was using yellow paper. Or the person who was asked to put in disk number 1 and then disk number 2 and then disk number 3 only to complain that it was very difficult getting disk number 2 in and how will i ever get disk number 3 in the same drive. I guess we can be happy that computers no longer have disk drives. Your Mom will eventually come around like the rest of us and embrace this intuitive technology called a computer. Perhaps our children will someday laugh “with” us when we don’t understand “their technology” and they ask us why we keep insisting on using “a computer”. Thanks for the post.
Just show her how to use Skype with the grandkids and then you’ll see how quickly she’ll be motivated to pickup on high-tech!
Hi Tom Not normally my thing to comment on blogs & such but reading through this one amused & reminded me of time spent teaching my own mother to use a computer some years ago now (Windows 3.11 no less!): Curious methods of using the mouse; Finding her happily deleting entirely well crafted paragraphs of text due to a spelling mistake spotted above (ah… mum these arrow keys…); and a good few years more recently entering a fully formed paragraph into the Yahoo! search box when trying to find the answer to a question This winter I gifted her an Amazon Kindle eBook and a week later watched as she happily demonstrated the device and the Amazon store to a friend. My work (at least as a teacher. I will likely never escape my role in Support) is done.
Dear Mr Glocer: This comment has nothing to do with this post but it was the only way I could reach you. It
Hello Tom What fun it was to read your latest aloud to my girlfriend (she’s making dinner and I said “Hey let’s look at the latest on Tom Glocer’s blog”). She laughed much — her son just bought her mom (his grandma) a Mac Book Pro. I remember your mom back in the day (Columbia). Happy to hear all’s well! Best Tom Gettler
Thomas Henry: Nice piece. Your style and sense of humor come through clearly. Glad to see your mom is doing well. Please give her my best wishes. Regards Jamie Speyer
Tom from the sounds of it your mother is further along in the tech world than your sister who has no interest in learning how to email. Teaching your sister how to use the built-in TV guide on her TV was quite the task – she had the same issue Ursula must’ve had with understanding how scrolling on a screen works. Something that seems so basic to computer-literate people is so out of this world to people unfamiliar with technology… Brad (Anita’s grandson)
To make the long story short by 10 am tuesday morning I had my wallet back. There are no words to express my amazement and thanks. I never thought anyone in the whole wide world would take the time and trouble to search for the owner of a lost wallet. I read that Mr. Talmas aside from his day to day duties at T-R runs a program in alliance with globoforce that rewards employees that go beyond the call of duty so let me tell you he is a prime and living example of that attitude. I congratulate you in having people of that moral caliber working at your company.